Conducting Effective Policy Reviews

The following are the main reasons to conduct policy reviews:

• Ensure Compliance: Laws and regulations change over time, and policies must reflect these changes to avoid legal risks or penalties.
• Adapt to Agency Changes: As agencies grow or shift their strategic focus, policies need to adapt. Reviewing policies ensures they align with new goals, processes, and technologies.
• Improve Clarity: Over time, policies may become outdated, unclear, or redundant. Regular reviews ensure that policies remain understandable and relevant to the people they impact.
• Mitigate Risk: Gaps in policies can expose an agency to risk. A review process helps identify and address potential risks before they become problematic.

The following are key steps in conducting an effective policy review.

1. Establish Objectives and Scope: The first step in conducting a policy review is to clearly define the objectives. Are you reviewing policies for legal compliance, operational efficiency, or alignment with strategic goals like customer experience? Determine the scope — whether it’s a full agency review or focused on a specific department or function.
2. Assemble the Review Team: A successful policy review requires input from various stakeholders across the agency. Assemble a cross-functional team that includes representatives from legal, human resources, compliance, and relevant agency units. Involving different perspectives ensures that the review is comprehensive and considers all angles of the agency’s operations.
3. Collect and Organize Existing Policies: Gather existing policies and organize them for review. This is particularly important for larger agencies where policies may be scattered across different departments or formats. Ensure that the review team has access to the most current versions of each policy.
4. Evaluate the Relevance and Accuracy of Each Policy: Review each policy thoroughly to ensure it remains relevant, accurate, and legally compliant. Ask key questions during the evaluation process:

• Is the policy still relevant? Does it align with the current goals and operations of the agency?
• Is it clear and understandable? Are there areas where employees may find the policy confusing or difficult to follow?
• Is the policy compliant with current laws and regulations? Review the policy against applicable laws, industry standards, and best practices.

5. Identify Gaps or Overlaps: During the review, you may identify gaps where policies do not provide sufficient guidance or protection, or where existing policies overlap and create redundancy or confusion.
6. Update or Draft New Policies: Based on the findings, update outdated policies or draft new ones to address gaps or new agency needs. Ensure that updates reflect current legal requirements and best practices. It’s important to balance detail with clarity — policies should be specific enough to provide guidance but clear enough to avoid confusion.
7. Communicate Changes and Train Staff: After approval, communicate the policy changes to employees clearly and effectively. Policies are only effective if employees understand them. Offer training, if necessary, to ensure staff know how to comply with new or revised policies.
8. Monitor and Review Regularly: Policy review should not be a one-time event. Establish a regular review cycle (e.g., annually or biannually) to ensure policies remain relevant and effective over time. Regular reviews allow you to adapt to changes in laws, technology, and agency strategies.

Sign up to get involved in the New York Experience.

SIGN UP